Live Bait Debate

[mikedatiger]

Let me first start by saying I have absolutely no problem with people fishing with live bait, but here's the question:

Is catching a trophy trout with live bait equal to catching a trophy trout on an artificial lure?

Let the fun begin!

[supercajun]

throw whatever they are biting... i like to catch fish so ill throw whatever but i usually stick with artificial cause its easier to deal with

[mikedatiger]

Originally Posted by supercajun

throw whatever they are biting... i like to catch fish so ill throw whatever but i usually stick with artificial cause its easier to deal with

question is whether or not, say an 8lber caught on live bait is considered equal to an 8lber caught on a plastic.

[Salty]

Originally Posted by mikedatiger

Let me first start by saying I have absolutely no problem with people fishing with live bait, but here's the question:

Is catching a trophy trout with live bait equal to catching a trophy trout on an artificial lure?

Let the fun begin!

IMO, it shouldn't qualify you as a "Trout Master".

Live bait should not be allowed in tournaments, IMO.

[huntin fool]

Originally Posted by mikedatiger

Let me first start by saying I have absolutely no problem with people fishing with live bait, but here's the question:

Is catching a trophy trout with live bait equal to catching a trophy trout on an artificial lure?

Let the fun begin!

I could give a flip less, and I do plan on soaking some tomorrow night asterick

[southern151]

This horse has been beaten to death a million times here!

Live shrimp or plastic and an 8 lb result... It's as good as stuffed on my wall!

[Salty]

Originally Posted by southern151

This horse has been beaten to death a million times here!

Live shrimp or plastic and a 3 lb result... It's as good as stuffed on my wall!

[southern151]

Originally Posted by Salty

Lol! You right on that! At this point, I'd settle for a wet line and bare hook! No time to go with work, a business and, a wife and two small children!

Wunt to cunpear salerys?!

[Jordan]

Popcorn anybody ?

[Salty]

Originally Posted by Jordan

Popcorn shrimp anybody ?

[southern151]

You need to go back to work or.... Somethin! Lol

[Salty]

Originally Posted by southern151

You need to go back to work or.... Somethin! Lol

I am....tomorrow.

[trophytroutman]

In my opinion fish with what you feel confidence in and legal.8lbs is 8lbs.I prefer artys myself and feel its more sporting catching them on artys than live bait.I like the challenge of working a bait and looking for the fish rather than soaking live bait and letting the fish find you.Not saying I wont fish with live bait.This is a very touchy subject.I agree live bait shouldnt be used in tournaments except if its for a charity.You will get more participants for a charity if you have live bait and that means more for the charity.Just my 2cents.

[mikedatiger]

Originally Posted by huntin fool

I could give a flip less, and I do plan on soaking some tomorrow night asterick

only thing you'll be soaking is the net

[LaAngler]

I'm not getting sucked into this one.

(had a big paragraph written but deleted it...)

[Gerald]

The same argument can be said for Deer hunting while sitting in front of a pile of corn.

Some do it.....some don't.

[PUREBAY2200]

Ummmmm new topic.
Who cares....???
If u catch the trout then u caught it... Live or arti... U still caught it.

[meaux fishing]

its not like everybody that fishes live bait catches big fish... so it still takes some skill to catch big fish either way.

[MallardFish]

Originally Posted by meaux fishing

its not like everybody that fishes live bait catches big fish... so it still takes some skill to catch big fish either way.

Good point Meaux. And you still have to have some kind of idea where this 8lb. trout will be, fight the beast and put it in the boat (boga or whatever). I like fishing the fake stuff, but if I caught a hog on the live ones it would make no difference to me.

[BArmand]

I like to fish atrificials tipped with live shrimp