The Keys or The Islands ???

[simplepeddler]

The Caribbean hands down.
We have been blessed to be on several Islands.
For the budget you are looking for.....all inclusive is the way to go.
I suggest you take a ride to a book store and pick up a "Caribbean" magazine and they will many to choose from.

Don't shy away from places like Dominican republic or the Tortolas
We don't do the beach as more because we are a little longer in the tooth, but we really enjoy the snorkeling around St. John's.
We stay at Gallos Point and cook our on meals, kinda like a condo at Orange Beach or something. Saves us a ton of money.

Congrats man!! and Good luck