Haynie vs. Blackjack

[Bdub]

Its possible a haynie could be the #1 guide boat on the lake, **** I seen 3 of them today one in west cove 2 in prien. I was told by a capt last year about this time that Grosse Savanne had a big order in to replace all their boats but not sure if that went through or what. The haynie is a beast in a chop ive seen it first hand. But you gotta really compare the two. Just because its a custom boat doesn't make it better. When you walk across a flush mount hatch lid and hear it crack then there is a problem with quality control. When you have a boat that is much more mass produced there is more quality control as every boat goes through the same ringer. The cap and rear deck on a haynie look cheap to me. Cheap nonskid, webbing, very basic rolled edge compared to a molded in texture cap on the blackjack. Why would they mention no exposed wood if they just said no rot board? Are they using Nida core?What kind of resin are they using? Now having a lifetime warranty is pretty nice, but has anyone dealt with warranty issues and how is the service with that? As for the guide program...of course guides would go with the best deal if the boat is capable of bringing a crew and slingin trout.

I have not been in a blackjack, but for a little extra would prefer the boat that is better fit and finish and offers more options for the passengers on board. I cant afford either one so I'd take one of each if they were giving them away. Rule #1 when buying a boat...wet test, wet test, wet test. And then wet test some more.

["W"]

Originally Posted by Bdub

Its possible a haynie could be the #1 guide boat on the lake, **** I seen 3 of them today one in west cove 2 in prien. I was told by a capt last year about this time that Grosse Savanne had a big order in to replace all their boats but not sure if that went through or what. The haynie is a beast in a chop ive seen it first hand. But you gotta really compare the two. Just because its a custom boat doesn't make it better. When you walk across a flush mount hatch lid and hear it crack then there is a problem with quality control. When you have a boat that is much more mass produced there is more quality control as every boat goes through the same ringer. The cap and rear deck on a haynie look cheap to me. Cheap nonskid, webbing, very basic rolled edge compared to a molded in texture cap on the blackjack. Why would they mention no exposed wood if they just said no rot board? Are they using Nida core?What kind of resin are they using? Now having a lifetime warranty is pretty nice, but has anyone dealt with warranty issues and how is the service with that? As for the guide program...of course guides would go with the best deal if the boat is capable of bringing a crew and slingin trout.

I have not been in a blackjack, but for a little extra would prefer the boat that is better fit and finish and offers more options for the passengers on board. I cant afford either one so I'd take one of each if they were giving them away. Rule #1 when buying a boat...wet test, wet test, wet test. And then wet test some more.

Evis cracked his hull in an accident and it was replaced

Grosse Savanne has 3 or 4 Haynies
As far as flush mount hatch lid,,, you can pick the cheep ones or the ones that are heavy duty.... I have never changed a lid on my boat or had one crack. My lids are solid and well made but I paid for them when built the boat.....

You can stand 600bls on my lids and you will not hear them crack ….but lot of guys choose the cheaper ones to cut cost ….

[Bdub]

I'm not talking about the ones you cut a hole and replace with frame, those are great. Found this pic with a quick search...these are the ones im referring to. Either way if it has a lifetime warranty (which I didn't know) then I'd just call and have a new hatch lid sent to me.
http://2coolfishing.com/ttmbforum/at...1&d=1368257603

["W"]

Originally Posted by Bdub

I'm not talking about the ones you cut a hole and replace with frame, those are great. Found this pic with a quick search...these are the ones im referring to. Either way if it has a lifetime warranty (which I didn't know) then I'd just call and have a new hatch lid sent to me.
http://2coolfishing.com/ttmbforum/at...1&d=1368257603

I have never seen or even heard of a problem with those holes....

[Dogface]

W, which model do you have?

[Bdub]

Its not the holes im speaking of, the way the hatches were not mounted properly...makes me second guess craftsmanship.

["W"]

Originally Posted by Dogface

W, which model do you have?

I have the Z21

Originally Posted by Bdub

Its not the holes im speaking of, the way the hatches were not mounted properly...makes me second guess craftsmanship.

I still dont understand what you are talking about when you say not mounted properly??

[specknation]

My buddy just texted me said he has read all post and said who is that W dude does he work for Haynie LOL

[Salty]

Originally Posted by specknation

My buddy just texted me said he has read all post and said who is that W dude does he work for Haynie LOL

Why doesn't your "buddy" become a member so he can converse on his own? Would his name happen to be "Dean"?

[ckinchen]

Originally Posted by Salty

Why doesn't your "buddy" become a member so he can converse on his own? Would his name happen to be "Dean"?

Because this is a classic troll thread. The op starts threads like this every few months to sit back and watch it implode. Some choose to feed the trolls.

[Salty]

Originally Posted by ckinchen

Because this is a classic troll thread. The op starts threads like this every few months to sit back and watch it implode. Some choose to feed the trolls.

That's why I asked.

[specknation]

Originally Posted by Salty

That's why I asked.

Look back I do not start threads, matter of fact this is the first thread I have ever started LOL

[Goooh]

Originally Posted by "W"

Yep and its the same Fan Club

Edwards (as called in gill net puregay)
Southern101(aka suckie suckie)
Salty(aka last know boat ride was in the MayFlower)
NLK( new club member)
Rene (aka ASR tDUCK)


Did I miss anyone???

[all star rod]

And let's see.....BRUH's....aka "W".... PRO Hiney Club = they are hoping and praying for a FISHING TRIP with MR HINEY himself.......

1. Flounderpacker
1A. GOOOH

Did I miss anyone?????

[flounder_smacker]

Originally Posted by all star rod

First off BRUH, I did not say crap about either boat..i made a comment in regards to a post by bluechip....get over it...this not the sports bar so keep your crap there and not in the open forums...I could care less if hineys are the #1 selling boat in the US...

Originally Posted by all star rod

And let's see.....BRUH's....aka "W".... PRO Hiney Club = they are hoping and praying for a FISHING TRIP with MR HINEY himself.......

1. Flounderpacker
1A. GOOOH

Did I miss anyone?????

telling people keep it premium. does exactly the opposite 3 post later.
i guess you are a general discussion guy these days since you got butt raped in the sports bar. lol lmao lm fao lm faoX100000

["W"]

I dont care if its a troll thread or not

I love pulling my ducks out of the tall grass every now and then

1) Southern1o1 ( aka mr paint n body guy who joins in every haynie thread but never stepped foot in one)
2) puregay ( aka mr boat expert of every make and model due to looking at them from the parking lots)
3) Salty ( old as the 1st boat ever made)
4) Rene "ASR" ( aka famous for lol,lmao,lol,lmao at the end of every statement) )
5) NLK (newest member who has no clue what fiberglass is)

[all star rod]

Originally Posted by flounder_smacker

telling people keep it premium. does exactly the opposite 3 post later.
i guess you are a general discussion guy these days since you got butt raped in the sports bar. lol lmao lm fao lm faoX100000

[homerun]

The guy going to bat the most for haynie actually thought some fishing rods were filled with helium to make them lighter. Who would take this guy seriously when anyone need a logical answer.

[ckinchen]

There is no guy he knows looking to make this choice and if there were they can use the search feature to view the 798 threads we have comparing these two boats. Of cousrse several ended up in the gill net.

[specknation]

Originally Posted by ckinchen

There is no guy he knows looking to make this choice and if there were they can use the search feature to view the 798 threads we have comparing these two boats. Of cousrse several ended up in the gill net.

Wow calling me a liar for starting this thread, I am speechless isn't this a fishing boating site whatever.