Daisy cutter or short barrel?

[noodle creek]

i guide 59 days a year in a freshwater marsh south of lake arthur. i blow a $40 call and killed 389 mallards last year. It's more knowing when to call than sounding exactly like a duck and $140 call will not help you kill more birds. In Louisiana we kill mostly grays, teal, wigeon, and pintails, so a whistle is better most of the time anyway